Table 1

Group characteristics for the subgroups

NoAge% womenBMITegnerFollow-up (year)% symptomatic knee*PASS pain
%†
PASS symptom %†PASS ADL %†PASS sport/Rec %†PASS QOL %†
Younger
APM
5029.1 (±4.1)36.025.3 (±3.8)5.5 (±2.9)4.0 (±1.2)66.086.050.080.068.068.0
 Suture3126.3 (±4.5)35.524.7 (±3.0)5.0 (±2.9)4.0 (±1.5)64.580.648.883.971.064.5
 APM+ACLR3027.5 (±4.6)40.026.0 (±5.0)5.2 (±2.5)5.0 (±1.2)66.773.360.076.776.766.7
 Suture+ACLR3926.0 (±4.6)59.026.1 (±3.6)5.0 (±2.8)4.6 (±1.2)53.874.461.587.274.459.0
Middle-aged
APM
19646.4 (±5.2)33.225.8 (±3.6)3.2 (±1.9)3.9 (±1.4)62.268.962.874.565.860.2
 Suture2142.8 (±6.1)23.826.1 (±3.2)3.2 (±2.2)3.7 (±1.2)66.781.071.485.766.738.1
 APM+ACLR3244.2 (±6.4)34.424.9 (±3.2)3.3 (±1.9)4.9 (±1.4)59.484.468.887.581.375.0
 Suture+ACLR2244.0 (±5.2)45.525.3 (±3.0)3.2 (±1.7)4.7 (±1.3)54.590.968.290.977.377.3
  • Describing the mean age, BMI and Tegner of the study group as well as percent symptomatic knee and percent above PASS in the subscales for each group.

  • BMI, body mass index; ADL, Activities of daily living; QOL, quality of life

  • *According to the definition by Englund et al.25

  • †According to PASS-value from Pedersen et al.26

  • ACLR, anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction; ADL, Activities of daily living; APM, arthroscopic partial meniscectomy; BMI, body mass index; PASS, patient’s acceptable symptom state; QOL, quality of life.