Author (year) | Design | Intervention programme | Intervention group | Comparison group(s) |
Schmidt et al 27 (2013) δ | NRCT | 24 weeks; 2/week; 60 min. | ST: indoor; 4–6 players a side; 5×10 min SSG; 1.2 sessions/week completed; 82% HRmax. | CG: maintain daily lifestyle. |
Andersen et al 28 (2014)δ | NRCT | As above (see Schmidt et al, 2013). | As above (see Schmidt et al, 2013), but 1.5 sessions/week completed with average intensity of 83% HRmax. | As above (see Schmidt et al, 2013). |
Schmidt et al 22 (2014)α | RCT | 12 months; (month 1–4) 2/week, (month 5–12) 3/week; 1hour. | ST: outdoor/indoor; 3–5 players a side; supervised, (months 1–3) 3×15 min SSG, (months 3–12) 4×15 min SSG; 66% of all sessions completed. | RT: supervised, 5 UL and LL ex (two additional exercises added from week 25) and 5 min core training, (months 0–3) 3 sets/ex with 1.5 min rest, (months 3–12) 4 sets/ex with 3 min rest, (months 0–1) 16–20 RM, (months 2–12) 8–12 RM; 73% of all sessions completed.CG: maintain usual lifestyle. |
Andersen et al 29 (2014)α | RCT | 16 weeks; 2/week; 1 hour. | As above (see Schmidt et al, 2014), but only played outdoors (4–6 players a side), 77.1% of all sessions completed with average intensity of ~82% HRmax. | As above (see Schmidt et al, 2014), but 74.1% of all sessions completed. |
Helge et al 30 (2014)α | RCT | As above (see Schmidt et al, 2014). | As above (see Schmidt et al, 2014), but only played outdoors with average intensity of ~82% HRmax. | As above (see Schmidt et al, 2014), but the rest interval for weeks 13–52 was 1.5 min. |
Andersen et al 31 (2016)α | RCT | As above (see Schmidt et al, 2014) | As above (see Schmidt et al, 2014). | As above (see Schmidt et al, 2014), but the rest interval for weeks 13–52 was 1.5 min. |
Sundstrup et al 32 (2016)α | RCT | As above (see Schmidt et al, 2014). | As above (see Schmidt et al, 2014), but 4–5 players a side with average intensity of ~82% HRmax. | As above (see Schmidt et al, 2014), but the rest interval for weeks 13–52 was 1.5 min. |
Uth et al 33 (2014)γ | RCT | 12 weeks; (weeks 1–8) 2/week, (weeks 9–12) 3/week; (weeks 1–4) 45 min, (weeks 5–12) 1hour. | ST: outdoor/indoor; 5–7 players a side; supervised, (weeks 1–4) 2×15 min and (weeks 5–12) 3×15 min SSG; 76.5% of all sessions completed; 84.6% HRmax. | CG: maintain daily lifestyle. |
Uth et al 34 (2016)γ | RCT | 32 weeks; (weeks 1–8) 2/week, (weeks 9–12) 3/week, (weeks 13–32) 2/week; (weeks 0–4) 45 min, (weeks 5–32) 1 hour. | ST: supervised (weeks 1–4) 2×15 min SSG, (weeks 5–32) 3×15 min SSG; 46.2%–76.5% of all sessions completed. | As above (see Uth et al, 2014). |
Uth et al 35 (2016)γ | RCT | As above (see Uth et al, 2014). | As above (see Uth et al, 2014), but 3–7 players a side without reporting training intensity. | As above (see Uth et al, 2014). |
de Sousa et al 36 (2014)β | RUT | 12 weeks; (NC) 1/week; (NEP) 1/2 weeks; (SSG) 3/week; (NEP) 1 hour; (SSG) 40 min. | ST: outdoor/indoor; 3–7 players a side; 2×12 min SSG; >70% to >90% HRmaxDI: NC and NEP (cut 500–1000 kcal/day/subject). | DI: NC and NEP (cut 500–1000 kcal/day/subject). |
de Sousa et al 37 (2017)β | RUT | As above (see de Sousa et al, 2014). | As above (see de Sousa et al, 2014), but training was supervised. | As above (see de Sousa et al, 2014). |
Reddy et al 38 (2017) | RCT | 12 weeks; 1/week; 1hour. | ST: outdoor; 5 players a side; walking soccer games; average 9.4 sessions completed; 76% HRmax. | CG: maintain daily lifestyle. |
α, β,γ,δ: Studies based on the same trial.
As trial results are described in more than one paper, the bolded study represents the first published paper from a given exercise trial.
CG, control group; DI, dietary intervention; ex, exercise; HRmax, maximum heart rate; LL, lower limb; NC, nutritional counselling; NEP, Nutritional Education Programme; NRCT, non-randomised controlled trial; RCT, randomised controlled trial; RM, repetition maximum; RT, resistance training; RUT, randomised uncontrolled trial; SSG, small-sided games; ST, soccer training; UL, upper limb.